This implements support for arbitrary service types on properties,
not just the weakly typed "service". For example, in the AWS stacks,
the aws/ec2/route type requires a routeTable, among other things:
name: aws/ec2/route
properties:
routeTable:
type: aws/ec2/routeTable
This not only binds the definition of such properties, but also the
callsites of those creating stacks and supplying values for them.
This includes checking for concrete, instantiated, and even base
types, so that, for instance, if a custom stack derived from
aws/ec2/routeTable using the base property, in the above example
it could be supplied as a legal value for the routeTable property.
Now that we're actually type-checking property types, a number of the
AWS stacks began failing, because we haven't yet mapped the full set of
resource types. I began doing that for the missing ones, but pulling on
that thread just leads to an even larger set ... (possibly all of them!)
due to extra dependencies. For now, since they aren't required for the
basic scenario, I'll just comment these out; I've logged marapongo/mu#27
to track mapping the full set of resource types.
The previous code stored dependencies in a map. This caused non-determinism
in the order in which the resulting dependencies would be bound. Instead of
doing that, this change tracks them in an array, simply using a map to avoid
binding duplicate dependencies.
A stack property can refer to other stack types. For example:
properties:
gateway:
type: aws/ec2/internetGateway
...
In such cases, we need to validate the property during binding,
in addition to binding it to an actual type so that we can later
validate callers who are constructing instances of this stack
and providing property values that we must typecheck.
Note that this binding is subtly different than existing stack
type binding. All the name validation, resolution, and so forth
are the same. However, notice that in this case we are not actually
supplying any property setters. That is, internetGateway is not
an "expanded" type, in that we have not processed any of its templates.
An analogy might help: this is sort of akin referring to an
uninstantiated generic type in a traditional programming language,
versus its instantiated form. In this case, certain properties aren't
available to us, however we can still use it for type identity, etc.
This change properly transforms literal AST nodes during code-gen.
This includes emitting CloudFormation !Refs where appropriate, for
intra-stack references (capability types).
This change adds a handful of property binding tests.
It also fixes:
* AsName should assert IsName.
* Enumerate properties stably, so that it is deterministic.
* Do not issue errors about unrecognized properties for the special
`mu/extension` type. It's entire purpose in life is to offer an
entirely custom set of properties, which the provider is meant to
validate.
* Default to an empty map if properties are missing.
* Add a "/" to the end of the namespace from the workspace, if present.
And rearranges some code:
* Rename the LiteralX types to XLiteral; e.g., StringLiteral instead of
LiteralString. I kept typing XLiteral erroneously.
* Eliminate the Mu prefix on all of the predefined type and service
functions and types. It's superfluous and reads nicer this way.
* Swap the order of "expected" vs. "got" in the error message about
incorrect property types. It used to say "got %v, expected %v"; I
personally find that it is more helpful if it says "expected %v,
got %v". YMMV.
This change permits a workspace to specify a namespace, which is just a name
part that is trimmed off the front of directories when probing for inter-
workspace dependencies. For example, if our namespace is aws/, normally we'd
need to organize our namespace into directories like:
<root>
| aws/
| | dynamodb/
| | ec2/
| | s3/
... and so on ...
If we instead specify a namespace
namespace: aws
Then we can instead organize our project workspace as follows:
<root>
| dynamodb/
| ec2/
| s3/
... and so on ...
This is an initial pass at property binding. For all stack instantiations,
we must verify that the set of properties supplied are correct. We also must
remember the bound property information so that code-generation has all of
the information it needs to generate correct code (including capability refs).
This entails:
* Ensuring required properties are provided.
* Expanding missing properties that have Default values.
* Type-checking that supplied properties are of the right type.
* Expanding property values into AST literal nodes.
To do this requires a third AST pass in the semantic analysis part of the
compiler. In the 1st pass, dependencies aren't even known yet; in the 2nd
pass, dependencies have not yet been bound; therefore, we need a 3rd pass,
which can depend on the full binding information for the transitive closure
of AST nodes and dependencies to have been populated with types.
There are a few loose ends in here:
* We don't yet validate top-level stack properties.
* We don't yet validate top-level stack base type properties.
* We don't yet support complex schema property types.
* We don't yet support even "simple" complex property types, like `[ string ]`.
* We don't yet support strongly typed capability property types (just `service`).
That said, I am going to turn to writing a few tests for the basic cases, and then
resume to finishing this afterwards (tracked by marapongo/mu#25).
The prior code could miss arrays of strings during conversion because
the arrays created by the various marshalers are weakly typed. In other
words, even though they contain strings, the array type is []interface{}.
This change introduces the encoding.ArrayOfStrings function to perform
this conversion, first by checking for []string and returning that directly
where possible, and second, if that fails, checking each element and copying.
This changes the way binding dependencies works slightly, to ensure that
the full transitive closure of dependencies is bound appropriately before
hitting code-generation. Namely, now binder.PrepareStack returns a list
of unresolved dependency Refs; the compiler is responsible for turning this
into a map from Ref to the loaded diag.Document, before calling BindStack;
then, BindStack instantiates these as necessary (template expansion, etc),
returning an array of unbound *ast.Stacks that the compiler must then bind.
Well, it turns out glog.Fail is slightly better than panic, because it explicitly
dumps the stacks of *all* goroutines. This is especially good in logging scenarios.
It's really annoying that glog suppresses printing the stack trace (see here
https://github.com/golang/glog/blob/master/glog.go#L719), however this is better.
This change switches away from using glog.Fatalf, and instead uses panic,
should a fail-fast arise (due to a call to util.Fail or a failed assertion
by way of util.Assert). This leads to a better debugging experience no
matter what flags have been passed to glog. For example, glog.Fatal* seems
to suppress printing stack traces when --logtostderr is supplied.
This change moves parse-tree analysis into the Parse* functions, so that
any callers doing parsing don't need to do this as a multi-step activity.
(We had neglected to do the parse-tree analysis phase during dependency
resolution, for example, meaning services were left untyped.)
This change makes workspace file naming a little more consistent with respect
to Mufile naming. Instead of having a .mu/ directory, under which a workspace.yaml
and/or a stacks directory might exist, we now have a Muspace.yaml (or .json) file,
and a .Mudeps/ directory. This has nicer symmetric with respect to Mu.yaml files.
If compiling a stack that accepts properties directly, we need a way to
pass arguments to that stack at the command line. This change permits this
using the ordinary "--" style delimiter; for example:
$ mu build -- --name=Foo
This is super basic and doesn't handle all the edge cases, but is sufficient
for testing and prototyping purposes.
I wasn't sure at first how we'd distinguish between strings and cap names.
At first, I thought we'd need special syntax, e.g. `<vpn>`; however, now I
am leaning towards a "type inference" approach, where we will interpret the
string as a cap name rather than string if that's what the target property
expects. Although this isn't quite as explicitly typed, that's probably a
good thing in this case, as it eliminates verbosity and weird characters.
This change introduces the notion of "perturbing" properties. Changing
one of these impacts the live service, possibly leading to downtime. As
such, we will likely encourage blue/green deployments of them just to be
safe. Note that this is really just a placeholder so I can keep track of
metadata as we go, since AWS CF has a similar notion to this.
I'm not in love with the name. I considered `interrupts`, however,
I must admit I liked that `readonly` and `perturbs` are symmetric in
the number of characters (meaning stuff lines up nicely...)
To avoid injecting needless whitespace -- which is unfortunately meaningful
in YAML -- we need to use the new "-" trimming operators, available in Go 1.6.
This change detects the target cloud earlier on in the compilation process.
Prior to this change, we didn't know this information until the backend code-generation.
Clearly we need to know this at least by then, however, templates can specialize on this
information, so we actually need it sooner. This change moves it into the frontend part.
Note that to support this we now eliminate the ability to specify target clusters in
the Mufile alone. That "feels" right to me anyway, since Mufiles are supposed to be
agnostic to their deployment environment, other than template specialization. Instead,
this information can come from the CLI and/or the workspace settings file.
In some cases, a dependency will resolve to a diag.Document, rather than
a fully instantiated ast.Stack (in fact, that is the common case). The
binder needs to detect and tolerate this situation.
This change projects several EC2 Mu stacks that are required for Mu cluster
bootstrapping. This includes:
- aws/ec2/internetGateway
- aws/ec2/route
- aws/ec2/routeTable
- aws/ec2/securityGroup
- aws/ec2/subnet
- aws/ec2/vpc
- aws/ec2/vpcGatewayAttachment
This is still not complete, and in fact some of these reference other EC2
Stacks that do not yet exist. But we're getting a bit closer...
This change adds the notion of readonly properties to stacks. Although these
*can* be "changed", doing so implies recreation of the resources all over again.
As a result, all dependents must be recreated, in a cascading manner.
The "require" template function simply checks a condition and, if it
is false, issues an error and quits template processing immediately.
This is useful for concisely encoding validation logic.
In some cases, we actually want to suppress auto-mapping for all or
most of the properties. In those cases, it's easier to specify those
that we *do* want rather than the ones we *do not* want. Now with
properties, skipProperties, and extraProperties, we have all the
necessary flexibility to control auto-mapping for CF templates.
The new "has" function lets templates conveniently check the existence of
keys in property bag-like maps. For example:
{{if has .Properties "something"}}
...
{{end}}
Most properties in CF templates are auto-mapped by the aws/cf extension
provider. However, sometimes we want to inject extra properties that are
outside of that auto-mapping (like our convenient shortcut for supplying
name to mean adding a "Name=v" tag). And sometimes we want to skip auto-
mapping for certain properties (like our capability-based approach to
passing service references, versus string IDs).
This change adds a super simple initial whack at a basic cluster topology
comprised of VPC, subnet, internet gateway, attachments, and route tables.
This is actually written in Mu itself, and I am committing this early, since
there are quite a few features required before we can actually make progress
getting this up and running.
This introduces a "panic" template function, so that templates may abandon
evaluation if something unexpected occurs. It accepts a string, indicating
the error, and optional arguments, if the string is to be formatted.
For example:
{{if eq .Target "aws"}}
...
{{else}}
{{panic "Unrecognized cloud target: %v" .Target}}
{{end}}
This lets YAML files include others, often conditionally, based on things
like the cloud target. For example, I am currently using this to define the
overall cluster stack by doing things like:
name: mu/cluster
services:
{{if eq .Target "aws"}}
{{include "Mu-aws.yaml" | indent 4}}
{{else}}
...
{{end}}
This change performs template expansion both for root stack documents in
addition to the transitive closure of dependencies. There are many ongoing
design and implementation questions about how this should actually work;
please see marapongo/mu#7 for a discussion of them.