pulumi/pkg/engine/update.go
Pat Gavlin 6e5c4a38d8
Defer all diffs to resource providers. (#2849)
Thse changes make a subtle but critical adjustment to the process the
Pulumi engine uses to determine whether or not a difference exists
between a resource's actual and desired states, and adjusts the way this
difference is calculated and displayed accordingly.

Today, the Pulumi engine get the first chance to decide whether or not
there is a difference between a resource's actual and desired states. It
does this by comparing the current set of inputs for a resource (i.e.
the inputs from the running Pulumi program) with the last set of inputs
used to update the resource. If there is no difference between the old
and new inputs, the engine decides that no change is necessary without
consulting the resource's provider. Only if there are changes does the
engine consult the resource's provider for more information about the
difference. This can be problematic for a number of reasons:

- Not all providers do input-input comparison; some do input-state
  comparison
- Not all providers are able to update the last deployed set of inputs
  when performing a refresh
- Some providers--either intentionally or due to bugs--may see changes
  in resources whose inputs have not changed

All of these situations are confusing at the very least, and the first
is problematic with respect to correctness. Furthermore, the display
code only renders diffs it observes rather than rendering the diffs
observed by the provider, which can obscure the actual changes detected
at runtime.

These changes address both of these issues:
- Rather than comparing the current inputs against the last inputs
  before calling a resource provider's Diff function, the engine calls
  the Diff function in all cases.
- Providers may now return a list of properties that differ between the
  requested and actual state and the way in which they differ. This
  information will then be used by the CLI to render the diff
  appropriately. A provider may also indicate that a particular diff is
  between old and new inputs rather than old state and new inputs.

Fixes #2453.
2019-07-01 12:34:19 -07:00

359 lines
12 KiB
Go

// Copyright 2016-2018, Pulumi Corporation.
//
// Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
// you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
// You may obtain a copy of the License at
//
// http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
//
// Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
// distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
// WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
// See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
// limitations under the License.
package engine
import (
"sync"
"time"
"github.com/blang/semver"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/diag"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/resource"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/resource/deploy"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/resource/plugin"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/tokens"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/util/contract"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/util/logging"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/util/result"
"github.com/pulumi/pulumi/pkg/workspace"
)
// UpdateOptions contains all the settings for customizing how an update (deploy, preview, or destroy) is performed.
//
// This structre is embedded in another which uses some of the unexported fields, which trips up the `structcheck`
// linter.
// nolint: structcheck
type UpdateOptions struct {
// an optional set of analyzers to run as part of this deployment.
Analyzers []string
// the degree of parallelism for resource operations (<=1 for serial).
Parallel int
// true if debugging output it enabled
Debug bool
// true if the plan should refresh before executing.
Refresh bool
// true if the engine should use legacy diffing behavior during an update.
UseLegacyDiff bool
// true if we should report events for steps that involve default providers.
reportDefaultProviderSteps bool
// the plugin host to use for this update
host plugin.Host
}
// ResourceChanges contains the aggregate resource changes by operation type.
type ResourceChanges map[deploy.StepOp]int
// HasChanges returns true if there are any non-same changes in the resulting summary.
func (changes ResourceChanges) HasChanges() bool {
var c int
for op, count := range changes {
if op != deploy.OpSame {
c += count
}
}
return c > 0
}
func Update(u UpdateInfo, ctx *Context, opts UpdateOptions, dryRun bool) (ResourceChanges, result.Result) {
contract.Require(u != nil, "update")
contract.Require(ctx != nil, "ctx")
defer func() { ctx.Events <- cancelEvent() }()
info, err := newPlanContext(u, "update", ctx.ParentSpan)
if err != nil {
return nil, result.FromError(err)
}
defer info.Close()
emitter, err := makeEventEmitter(ctx.Events, u)
if err != nil {
return nil, result.FromError(err)
}
return update(ctx, info, planOptions{
UpdateOptions: opts,
SourceFunc: newUpdateSource,
Events: emitter,
Diag: newEventSink(emitter, false),
StatusDiag: newEventSink(emitter, true),
}, dryRun)
}
func installPlugins(
proj *workspace.Project, pwd, main string, target *deploy.Target,
plugctx *plugin.Context) (pluginSet, map[tokens.Package]*semver.Version, error) {
// Before launching the source, ensure that we have all of the plugins that we need in order to proceed.
//
// There are two places that we need to look for plugins:
// 1. The language host, which reports to us the set of plugins that the program that's about to execute
// needs in order to create new resources. This is purely advisory by the language host and not all
// languages implement this (notably Python).
// 2. The snapshot. The snapshot contains plugins in two locations: first, in the manifest, all plugins
// that were loaded are recorded. Second, all first class providers record the version of the plugin
// to which they are bound.
//
// In order to get a complete view of the set of plugins that we need for an update or query, we must
// consult both sources and merge their results into a list of plugins.
languagePlugins, err := gatherPluginsFromProgram(plugctx, plugin.ProgInfo{
Proj: proj,
Pwd: pwd,
Program: main,
})
if err != nil {
return nil, nil, err
}
snapshotPlugins, err := gatherPluginsFromSnapshot(plugctx, target)
if err != nil {
return nil, nil, err
}
allPlugins := languagePlugins.Union(snapshotPlugins)
// If there are any plugins that are not available, we can attempt to install them here.
//
// Note that this is purely a best-effort thing. If we can't install missing plugins, just proceed; we'll fail later
// with an error message indicating exactly what plugins are missing.
if err := ensurePluginsAreInstalled(allPlugins); err != nil {
logging.V(7).Infof("newUpdateSource(): failed to install missing plugins: %v", err)
}
// Collect the version information for default providers.
defaultProviderVersions := computeDefaultProviderPlugins(languagePlugins, allPlugins)
return allPlugins, defaultProviderVersions, nil
}
func newUpdateSource(
client deploy.BackendClient, opts planOptions, proj *workspace.Project, pwd, main string,
target *deploy.Target, plugctx *plugin.Context, dryRun bool) (deploy.Source, error) {
allPlugins, defaultProviderVersions, err := installPlugins(proj, pwd, main, target,
plugctx)
if err != nil {
return nil, err
}
// Once we've installed all of the plugins we need, make sure that all analyzers and language plugins are
// loaded up and ready to go. Provider plugins are loaded lazily by the provider registry and thus don't
// need to be loaded here.
const kinds = plugin.AnalyzerPlugins | plugin.LanguagePlugins
if err := ensurePluginsAreLoaded(plugctx, allPlugins, kinds); err != nil {
return nil, err
}
// If that succeeded, create a new source that will perform interpretation of the compiled program.
// TODO[pulumi/pulumi#88]: we are passing `nil` as the arguments map; we need to allow a way to pass these.
return deploy.NewEvalSource(plugctx, &deploy.EvalRunInfo{
Proj: proj,
Pwd: pwd,
Program: main,
Target: target,
}, defaultProviderVersions, dryRun), nil
}
func update(ctx *Context, info *planContext, opts planOptions, dryRun bool) (ResourceChanges, result.Result) {
planResult, err := plan(ctx, info, opts, dryRun)
if err != nil {
return nil, result.FromError(err)
}
var resourceChanges ResourceChanges
var res result.Result
if planResult != nil {
defer contract.IgnoreClose(planResult)
// Make the current working directory the same as the program's, and restore it upon exit.
done, chErr := planResult.Chdir()
if chErr != nil {
return nil, result.FromError(chErr)
}
defer done()
if dryRun {
// If a dry run, just print the plan, don't actually carry out the deployment.
resourceChanges, res = printPlan(ctx, planResult, dryRun)
} else {
// Otherwise, we will actually deploy the latest bits.
opts.Events.preludeEvent(dryRun, planResult.Ctx.Update.GetTarget().Config)
// Walk the plan, reporting progress and executing the actual operations as we go.
start := time.Now()
actions := newUpdateActions(ctx, info.Update, opts)
res = planResult.Walk(ctx, actions, false)
resourceChanges = ResourceChanges(actions.Ops)
if len(resourceChanges) != 0 {
// Print out the total number of steps performed (and their kinds), the duration, and any summary info.
opts.Events.updateSummaryEvent(actions.MaybeCorrupt, time.Since(start), resourceChanges)
}
}
}
return resourceChanges, res
}
// updateActions pretty-prints the plan application process as it goes.
type updateActions struct {
Context *Context
Steps int
Ops map[deploy.StepOp]int
Seen map[resource.URN]deploy.Step
MapLock sync.Mutex
MaybeCorrupt bool
Update UpdateInfo
Opts planOptions
}
func newUpdateActions(context *Context, u UpdateInfo, opts planOptions) *updateActions {
return &updateActions{
Context: context,
Ops: make(map[deploy.StepOp]int),
Seen: make(map[resource.URN]deploy.Step),
Update: u,
Opts: opts,
}
}
func (acts *updateActions) OnResourceStepPre(step deploy.Step) (interface{}, error) {
// Ensure we've marked this step as observed.
acts.MapLock.Lock()
acts.Seen[step.URN()] = step
acts.MapLock.Unlock()
// Skip reporting if necessary.
if shouldReportStep(step, acts.Opts) {
acts.Opts.Events.resourcePreEvent(step, false /*planning*/, acts.Opts.Debug)
}
// Inform the snapshot service that we are about to perform a step.
return acts.Context.SnapshotManager.BeginMutation(step)
}
func (acts *updateActions) OnResourceStepPost(
ctx interface{}, step deploy.Step,
status resource.Status, err error) error {
acts.MapLock.Lock()
assertSeen(acts.Seen, step)
acts.MapLock.Unlock()
// If we've already been terminated, exit without writing the checkpoint. We explicitly want to leave the
// checkpoint in an inconsistent state in this event.
if acts.Context.Cancel.TerminateErr() != nil {
return nil
}
reportStep := shouldReportStep(step, acts.Opts)
// Report the result of the step.
if err != nil {
if status == resource.StatusUnknown {
acts.MaybeCorrupt = true
}
errorURN := resource.URN("")
if reportStep {
errorURN = step.URN()
}
// Issue a true, bonafide error.
acts.Opts.Diag.Errorf(diag.GetPlanApplyFailedError(errorURN), err)
if reportStep {
acts.Opts.Events.resourceOperationFailedEvent(step, status, acts.Steps, acts.Opts.Debug)
}
} else if reportStep {
op, record := step.Op(), step.Logical()
if acts.Opts.isRefresh && op == deploy.OpRefresh {
// Refreshes are handled specially.
op, record = step.(*deploy.RefreshStep).ResultOp(), true
}
if step.Op() == deploy.OpRead {
record = ShouldRecordReadStep(step)
}
if record {
// Increment the counters.
acts.MapLock.Lock()
acts.Steps++
acts.Ops[op]++
acts.MapLock.Unlock()
}
// Also show outputs here for custom resources, since there might be some from the initial registration. We do
// not show outputs for component resources at this point: any that exist must be from a previous execution of
// the Pulumi program, as component resources only report outputs via calls to RegisterResourceOutputs.
if step.Res().Custom || acts.Opts.Refresh && step.Op() == deploy.OpRefresh {
acts.Opts.Events.resourceOutputsEvent(op, step, false /*planning*/, acts.Opts.Debug)
}
}
// See pulumi/pulumi#2011 for details. Terraform always returns the existing state with the diff applied to it in
// the event of an update failure. It's appropriate that we save this new state in the output of the resource, but
// it is not appropriate to save the inputs, because the resource that exists was not created or updated
// successfully with those inputs.
//
// If we were doing an update and got a `StatusPartialFailure`, the resource that ultimately gets persisted in the
// snapshot should be old inputs and new outputs. We accomplish that here by clobbering the new resource's inputs
// with the old inputs.
//
// This is a little kludgy given that these resources are global state. However, given the way that we have
// implemented the snapshot manager and engine today, it's the easiest way to accomplish what we are trying to do.
if status == resource.StatusPartialFailure && step.Op() == deploy.OpUpdate {
logging.V(7).Infof(
"OnResourceStepPost(%s): Step is partially-failed update, saving old inputs instead of new inputs",
step.URN())
new := step.New()
old := step.Old()
contract.Assert(new != nil)
contract.Assert(old != nil)
new.Inputs = make(resource.PropertyMap)
for key, value := range old.Inputs {
new.Inputs[key] = value
}
}
// Write out the current snapshot. Note that even if a failure has occurred, we should still have a
// safe checkpoint. Note that any error that occurs when writing the checkpoint trumps the error
// reported above.
return ctx.(SnapshotMutation).End(step, err == nil || status == resource.StatusPartialFailure)
}
func (acts *updateActions) OnResourceOutputs(step deploy.Step) error {
acts.MapLock.Lock()
assertSeen(acts.Seen, step)
acts.MapLock.Unlock()
// Skip reporting if necessary.
if shouldReportStep(step, acts.Opts) {
acts.Opts.Events.resourceOutputsEvent(step.Op(), step, false /*planning*/, acts.Opts.Debug)
}
// There's a chance there are new outputs that weren't written out last time.
// We need to perform another snapshot write to ensure they get written out.
return acts.Context.SnapshotManager.RegisterResourceOutputs(step)
}
func (acts *updateActions) OnPolicyViolation(urn resource.URN, d plugin.AnalyzeDiagnostic) {
acts.Opts.Events.policyViolationEvent(urn, d)
}