Only do rc_login ratelimiting on succesful login.

We were doing this in a number of places which meant that some login
code paths incremented the counter multiple times.

It was also applying ratelimiting to UIA endpoints, which was probably
not intentional.

In particular, some custom auth modules were calling
`check_user_exists`, which incremented the counters, meaning that people
would fail to login sometimes.

synapse/handlers/auth.py

@@ -35,7 +35,6 @@ from synapse.api.errors import (
     SynapseError,
     UserDeactivatedError,
 )
-from synapse.api.ratelimiting import Ratelimiter
 from synapse.handlers.ui_auth import INTERACTIVE_AUTH_CHECKERS
 from synapse.handlers.ui_auth.checkers import UserInteractiveAuthChecker
 from synapse.logging.context import defer_to_thread
@@ -102,9 +101,6 @@ class AuthHandler(BaseHandler):
                         login_types.append(t)
         self._supported_login_types = login_types
 
-        self._account_ratelimiter = Ratelimiter()
-        self._failed_attempts_ratelimiter = Ratelimiter()
-
         self._clock = self.hs.get_clock()
 
     @defer.inlineCallbacks
@@ -501,11 +497,8 @@ class AuthHandler(BaseHandler):
             multiple matches
 
         Raises:
-            LimitExceededError if the ratelimiter's login requests count for this
-                user is too high too proceed.
             UserDeactivatedError if a user is found but is deactivated.
         """
-        self.ratelimit_login_per_account(user_id)
         res = yield self._find_user_id_and_pwd_hash(user_id)
         if res is not None:
             return res[0]
@@ -572,8 +565,6 @@ class AuthHandler(BaseHandler):
             StoreError if there was a problem accessing the database
             SynapseError if there was a problem with the request
             LoginError if there was an authentication problem.
-            LimitExceededError if the ratelimiter's login requests count for this
-                user is too high too proceed.
         """
 
         if username.startswith("@"):
@@ -581,8 +572,6 @@ class AuthHandler(BaseHandler):
         else:
             qualified_user_id = UserID(username, self.hs.hostname).to_string()
 
-        self.ratelimit_login_per_account(qualified_user_id)
-
         login_type = login_submission.get("type")
         known_login_type = False
 
@@ -650,15 +639,6 @@ class AuthHandler(BaseHandler):
         if not known_login_type:
             raise SynapseError(400, "Unknown login type %s" % login_type)
 
-        # unknown username or invalid password.
-        self._failed_attempts_ratelimiter.ratelimit(
-            qualified_user_id.lower(),
-            time_now_s=self._clock.time(),
-            rate_hz=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.per_second,
-            burst_count=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.burst_count,
-            update=True,
-        )
-
         # We raise a 403 here, but note that if we're doing user-interactive
         # login, it turns all LoginErrors into a 401 anyway.
         raise LoginError(403, "Invalid password", errcode=Codes.FORBIDDEN)
@@ -710,10 +690,6 @@ class AuthHandler(BaseHandler):
         Returns:
             Deferred[unicode] the canonical_user_id, or Deferred[None] if
                 unknown user/bad password
-
-        Raises:
-            LimitExceededError if the ratelimiter's login requests count for this
-                user is too high too proceed.
         """
         lookupres = yield self._find_user_id_and_pwd_hash(user_id)
         if not lookupres:
@@ -742,7 +718,7 @@ class AuthHandler(BaseHandler):
             auth_api.validate_macaroon(macaroon, "login", user_id)
         except Exception:
             raise AuthError(403, "Invalid token", errcode=Codes.FORBIDDEN)
-        self.ratelimit_login_per_account(user_id)
+
         yield self.auth.check_auth_blocking(user_id)
         return user_id
 
@@ -912,35 +888,6 @@ class AuthHandler(BaseHandler):
         else:
             return defer.succeed(False)
 
-    def ratelimit_login_per_account(self, user_id):
-        """Checks whether the process must be stopped because of ratelimiting.
-
-        Checks against two ratelimiters: the generic one for login attempts per
-        account and the one specific to failed attempts.
-
-        Args:
-            user_id (unicode): complete @user:id
-
-        Raises:
-            LimitExceededError if one of the ratelimiters' login requests count
-                for this user is too high too proceed.
-        """
-        self._failed_attempts_ratelimiter.ratelimit(
-            user_id.lower(),
-            time_now_s=self._clock.time(),
-            rate_hz=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.per_second,
-            burst_count=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.burst_count,
-            update=False,
-        )
-
-        self._account_ratelimiter.ratelimit(
-            user_id.lower(),
-            time_now_s=self._clock.time(),
-            rate_hz=self.hs.config.rc_login_account.per_second,
-            burst_count=self.hs.config.rc_login_account.burst_count,
-            update=True,
-        )
-
 
 @attr.s
 class MacaroonGenerator(object):

synapse/rest/client/v1/login.py

@@ -92,8 +92,11 @@ class LoginRestServlet(RestServlet):
         self.auth_handler = self.hs.get_auth_handler()
         self.registration_handler = hs.get_registration_handler()
         self.handlers = hs.get_handlers()
+        self._clock = hs.get_clock()
         self._well_known_builder = WellKnownBuilder(hs)
         self._address_ratelimiter = Ratelimiter()
+        self._account_ratelimiter = Ratelimiter()
+        self._failed_attempts_ratelimiter = Ratelimiter()
 
     def on_GET(self, request):
         flows = []
@@ -202,6 +205,16 @@ class LoginRestServlet(RestServlet):
                 # (See add_threepid in synapse/handlers/auth.py)
                 address = address.lower()
 
+            # We also apply account rate limiting using the 3PID as a key, as
+            # otherwise using 3PID bypasses the ratelimiting based on user ID.
+            self._failed_attempts_ratelimiter.ratelimit(
+                (medium, address),
+                time_now_s=self._clock.time(),
+                rate_hz=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.per_second,
+                burst_count=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.burst_count,
+                update=False,
+            )
+
             # Check for login providers that support 3pid login types
             (
                 canonical_user_id,
@@ -211,7 +224,8 @@ class LoginRestServlet(RestServlet):
             )
             if canonical_user_id:
                 # Authentication through password provider and 3pid succeeded
-                result = yield self._register_device_with_callback(
+
+                result = yield self._complete_login(
                     canonical_user_id, login_submission, callback_3pid
                 )
                 return result
@@ -225,6 +239,21 @@ class LoginRestServlet(RestServlet):
                 logger.warning(
                     "unknown 3pid identifier medium %s, address %r", medium, address
                 )
+                # We mark that we've failed to log in here, as
+                # `check_password_provider_3pid` might have returned `None` due
+                # to an incorrect password, rather than the account not
+                # existing.
+                #
+                # If it returned None but the 3PID was bound then we won't hit
+                # this code path, which is fine as then the per-user ratelimit
+                # will kick in below.
+                self._failed_attempts_ratelimiter.can_do_action(
+                    (medium, address),
+                    time_now_s=self._clock.time(),
+                    rate_hz=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.per_second,
+                    burst_count=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.burst_count,
+                    update=True,
+                )
                 raise LoginError(403, "", errcode=Codes.FORBIDDEN)
 
             identifier = {"type": "m.id.user", "user": user_id}
@@ -236,29 +265,84 @@ class LoginRestServlet(RestServlet):
         if "user" not in identifier:
             raise SynapseError(400, "User identifier is missing 'user' key")
 
-        canonical_user_id, callback = yield self.auth_handler.validate_login(
+        if identifier["user"].startswith("@"):
-            identifier["user"], login_submission
+            qualified_user_id = identifier["user"]
+        else:
+            qualified_user_id = UserID(identifier["user"], self.hs.hostname).to_string()
+
+        # Check if we've hit the failed ratelimit (but don't update it)
+        self._failed_attempts_ratelimiter.ratelimit(
+            qualified_user_id.lower(),
+            time_now_s=self._clock.time(),
+            rate_hz=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.per_second,
+            burst_count=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.burst_count,
+            update=False,
         )
 
-        result = yield self._register_device_with_callback(
+        try:
+            canonical_user_id, callback = yield self.auth_handler.validate_login(
+                identifier["user"], login_submission
+            )
+        except LoginError:
+            # The user has failed to log in, so we need to update the rate
+            # limiter. Using `can_do_action` avoids us raising a ratelimit
+            # exception and masking the LoginError. The actual ratelimiting
+            # should have happened above.
+            self._failed_attempts_ratelimiter.can_do_action(
+                qualified_user_id.lower(),
+                time_now_s=self._clock.time(),
+                rate_hz=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.per_second,
+                burst_count=self.hs.config.rc_login_failed_attempts.burst_count,
+                update=True,
+            )
+            raise
+
+        result = yield self._complete_login(
             canonical_user_id, login_submission, callback
         )
         return result
 
     @defer.inlineCallbacks
-    def _register_device_with_callback(self, user_id, login_submission, callback=None):
+    def _complete_login(
-        """ Registers a device with a given user_id. Optionally run a callback
+        self, user_id, login_submission, callback=None, create_non_existant_users=False
-        function after registration has completed.
+    ):
+        """Called when we've successfully authed the user and now need to
+        actually login them in (e.g. create devices). This gets called on
+        all succesful logins.
+
+        Applies the ratelimiting for succesful login attempts against an
+        account.
 
         Args:
             user_id (str): ID of the user to register.
             login_submission (dict): Dictionary of login information.
             callback (func|None): Callback function to run after registration.
+            create_non_existant_users (bool): Whether to create the user if
+                they don't exist. Defaults to False.
 
         Returns:
             result (Dict[str,str]): Dictionary of account information after
                 successful registration.
         """
+
+        # Before we actually log them in we check if they've already logged in
+        # too often. This happens here rather than before as we don't
+        # necessarily know the user before now.
+        self._account_ratelimiter.ratelimit(
+            user_id.lower(),
+            time_now_s=self._clock.time(),
+            rate_hz=self.hs.config.rc_login_account.per_second,
+            burst_count=self.hs.config.rc_login_account.burst_count,
+            update=True,
+        )
+
+        if create_non_existant_users:
+            user_id = yield self.auth_handler.check_user_exists(user_id)
+            if not user_id:
+                user_id = yield self.registration_handler.register_user(
+                    localpart=UserID.from_string(user_id).localpart
+                )
+
         device_id = login_submission.get("device_id")
         initial_display_name = login_submission.get("initial_device_display_name")
         device_id, access_token = yield self.registration_handler.register_device(
@@ -285,7 +369,7 @@ class LoginRestServlet(RestServlet):
             token
         )
 
-        result = yield self._register_device_with_callback(user_id, login_submission)
+        result = yield self._complete_login(user_id, login_submission)
         return result
 
     @defer.inlineCallbacks
@@ -313,16 +397,7 @@ class LoginRestServlet(RestServlet):
             raise LoginError(401, "Invalid JWT", errcode=Codes.UNAUTHORIZED)
 
         user_id = UserID(user, self.hs.hostname).to_string()
-
+        result = yield self._complete_login(user_id, login_submission)
-        registered_user_id = yield self.auth_handler.check_user_exists(user_id)
-        if not registered_user_id:
-            registered_user_id = yield self.registration_handler.register_user(
-                localpart=user
-            )
-
-        result = yield self._register_device_with_callback(
-            registered_user_id, login_submission
-        )
         return result